Rhine Hall Strawberry Brandy
How do you find something that never really existed?
This was the problem I attempted to solve over the course of the past seven years when searching for an elusive bottle of Rhine Hall Strawberry Brandy. Of course the brandy actually existed or else it wouldn’t have been specified in the book, but there was no trace of it online or in liquor stores. And when I say no trace—I mean not even a photo or mention that it ever existed except for two recipes in The Aviary Cocktail Book: Good Night & Good Morning and Cawberry Strobbler.
Even the distributor for Rhine Hall in Colorado had never heard of it before. After a year of unfruitful searching at various local liquor stores, my go-to guy at Hazel’s Beverage World in Boulder suggested I level up my search. In 2020, I emailed the Colorado distributors to see if we could get some of their rarer flavors like Banana and Strawberry. They responded that they could get me Grappa, Apple, Oak Aged Apple, Plum, Mango, Cherry, La Normande, and Fernet Lola, but neither of the two I was looking for. At least that explained why none of the liquor stores in Colorado could special order a bottle for me. With no luck via my usual methods and enough other ingredients to search for, I demoted this search to passive status while we focused on making other cocktails.
In 2024, I resumed my search for several rare bottles, including the strawberry brandy. At this point, I was a bit savvier in my bottle-searching methods, so I thought I might get lucky. I began my search by reaching out to Rhine Hall directly and learned that my contact who previously found me a bottle of Banana Brandy was no longer with the company. I emailed a different contact listed on their website but never received a response. I looked in several online stores, used different combinations of keywords in my search, and combed through Rhine Hall’s social media accounts in hopes of seeing a bottle, but once again, I found nothing.
This was starting to be a real bummer. It was also a reminder not to take any of the other rare bottles on my list for granted and to consider substitutions. When searching for a substitute, I quickly realized that true strawberry brandy is incredibly rare. Look online and you can quite easily find strawberry liqueur or strawberry-flavored spirits like vodka. What is much harder is finding something that consists of pure strawberry distillate with no added sugars. Luckily, I found that in Metté Fraise Eau de Vie.
Until this point, I had never thought about there being a difference and what it might be. Eau de vie is a subset of brandy that is made with fruits other than grapes. Eau de vie is also typically clear and not aged, whereas brandy is typically aged in oak casks. It turns out, many of the products Rhine Hall produces are more like eau de vie than brandy. So although this product was categorized differently on the label, Metté Fraise Eau de Vie would serve as an excellent replacement for strawberry brandy. The key word here being would.
It would have been a great substitute. But it wasn’t. Many varieties of Metté eau de vie turn up in liquor stores all across Colorado…just not strawberry. I asked over half a dozen liquor stores with various other types of Metté eau de vie on their shelves if they could special order me a bottle. To be fair, they all tried. In the end, most of these stores were informed by their distributors that they couldn’t get a bottle and didn’t provide any further explanation. Finally, a rep at PJ’s Wine & Spirits in Longmont was able to offer a bit more information: The distributor was told they wouldn’t be exporting Metté to the United States for at least another year as strawberry crops were very poor over the past couple seasons. While disappointing, I was satisfied to finally hear an explanation.
What was worse is that in liquor stores across the country, every bottle of Metté I found online was an anomaly in that store’s inventory. Even when I called those stores directly, I learned that they had long ago sold out of strawberry eau de vie and had no plans to get more. This story was starting to sound a bit too familiar.
Growing desperate, I attempted to order a bottle from Metté directly from their distillery in France. Their online store lists it as one of the many varieties available. I’d recently had luck ordering bottles from Europe and having vacationing friends bring them back for me. However, I learned that Metté has pretty strict limitations around shipping and wouldn’t ship outside France. Nobody I knew had plans to travel to France anytime soon. My last-ditch scheme wasn’t going to work unless I was willing to fly to France myself (an alluring prospect, but too impractical even for the guy who routinely embarks on highly impractical side quests).
It was now late 2025, and once again having no luck, I shifted my sights to other rare bottles. In fact, I was days away from embarking on a liquor run where I would fly to Milwaukee, rent a car, and drive to four different stores between there and Chicago before meeting my friends for dinner at The Aviary’s sister restaurant, Next.
The liquor run went off without a hitch, and I was able to snag six bottles, including two other Rhine Hall brandies (their Apple and Reserve Apple varieties), as well as bottles of Tequila Cabeza, CH Distillery Peppercorn Vodka, Dumante Verdenoce Pistachio Liqueur, and Cody Road Rye Whiskey. And our meal at Next was excellent. Their theme was Outer Space, which was especially fun because we had no idea what kind of food would appear on an outer space-themed menu.

Examples of the kind of food that appeared on an outer space-themed menu. Is it too corny to describe the meal as being “out of this world”? Perhaps. I’ll take my chances anyway.
Our plan was to finish dinner and go next door to The Aviary for a drink to end the night. Once we settled in, I ordered a drink called Hermoso, as it was the only cocktail on their menu I recognized from the book. It was delicious—a smoked tequila concoction with orange and chocolate flavors, accompanied by a lovely chocolate cigar.
After finishing our first round, we decided to get one last drink before Ubering home. While everything I had that evening was delicious and of the highest quality, I was beginning to have an upset stomach—the cause of which was a different kind of side quest I would have rather avoided: Prior to dinner at Next, I spent most of my day in the emergency room at Masonic Medical Center treating an injury to my ear that had become unbearably painful since I landed in Chicago. After eight hours, I was discharged after taking my first dose of a strong antibiotic along with an even stronger painkiller. Piling several courses and cocktails on top of that medication was some questionable decision-making on my part, but I wasn’t about to miss out on this meal I’d been looking forward to for an entire year.
By now, I was powering through on pure adrenaline and fumes. While my friends opted to order cocktails, I decided to look at the spirits list in hopes of finding something herbal like an amaro to settle my stomach. Not at all in the mindset of bottle-hunting, I skimmed the list to find a selection simply labeled Strawberry Brandy.
Seeing this most elusive spirit on their menu was surreal. While I’d struck out time and again over the last seven years, I knew instantly that this had to be the Rhine Hall bottle. Hopeful but uncertain, I asked. Our server confirmed my suspicions. I couldn’t believe what was happening, but I ordered this elusive liquor, and within minutes, I was presented with both my pour and the bottle for inspection. A joyous photo op ensued.
The bottle was instantly recognizable as Rhine Hall—the bold solid-colored label with white print couldn’t be mistaken. Amazed—elated—highly medicated—I told our server about my years-long quest to obtain this very bottle and that I was never able to find so much as a passing reference to Rhine Hall’s strawberry variety in all my searching. (Note: If you have read along this far, you can imagine that this may not have been a short story.) Kind and amazingly patient, he spun the bottle around to reveal a small detail on the back of the label: a white circle with scalloped edges and an image of a bird inside—The Aviary’s logo. The emblem was labeled “SPECIAL EDITION EXCLUSIVELY PRODUCED FOR AVIARY.”
After all this searching, I am proud to know that these are likely the first photos of Rhine Hall Strawberry Brandy ever to be posted online.
And there you have it. The bottle that never existed was right there in my hands. It was never sold, distributed, or advertised to the public. It was made by Rhine Hall for The Aviary and has never appeared anywhere else.
Until this summer.
The label that explains everything.
That night at The Aviary, I was unable to confirm whether they could sell me this exclusive spirit. Confirming its existence was a victory in and of itself, but it wasn’t going to satisfy my desire to take it home and make cocktails with it. I emailed The Aviary to shoot my shot and was thrilled to learn that they were willing to sell me a bottle. They generously offered to hold it for me until the next time I visited.
Initially, I had hoped to return to Chicago in June or July but kept putting it off for a variety of reasons. Then August came, and with it, a vacation to Turkey and Georgia that Abe and I had been looking forward to for months. Knowing this big trip was on the horizon, and that I had plans to visit my friend Shara in Atlanta the week before our big vacation, I was reluctant to add another trip to the mix. But I was also starting to feel guilty that I hadn’t booked a Chicago trip sooner, and that the staff at The Aviary was holding onto this bottle for me for months with no clear pickup date. I decided to hold off just a little longer until we returned from our travel abroad.
Both Turkey and Georgia were incredible. While being quite different from one another, both countries contained a vibrant mix of cultures, languages, and histories. For me, the highlight of Turkey was the hammam in Istanbul, where I got to live out my fantasy of being a lizard basking on a hot stone slab, followed by a burial under mounds of lemongrass-scented suds. The combo of those two was easily the most relaxing feeling I have ever experienced. In Georgia, my favorite moment was getting hassled by the Mzia, the notorious elevator lady in Tbilisi who guards access to one of the most iconic examples of brutalist architecture in the country. She collects coins (exact change only) and warns you via a laminated sign in six different languages not to take photos when you get to the sky bridge at the top. Even through the language barrier, her gestures and tone of voice made it very clear what we were and were not allowed to do. It was amazing.
Mzia has operated the elevator to these apartments for over 20 years. She has only left the apartment complex once in that time to visit an area of Georgia that was special to her late husband.
Our flight home was broken up by a 24-hour stopover in Boston. We needed to connect there to get to Denver, and Abe had been eager to show me around as he’d lived there twice. Our international flights went smoothly, and we made it all the way to Boston without a hitch. That’s when things changed.
We arrived in the city tired but excited to explore what we could on our short visit. Just a few hours before we were set to leave for our flight home, we learned it was canceled due to mechanical issues, and that the soonest the airline could get us home was two days later. I spent a couple hours on the phone with customer service and found an option to fly through Chicago, spend the night, and leave by 6 AM the next morning. Then it occurred to me to ask if we could spend the day in Chicago and leave that night. My plan worked, though we managed to hit a weather delay and arrive in Chicago at 3 AM. For this reason alone, I’m glad we didn’t agree to the 6 AM flight to Denver.
Groggy as hell the next morning but excited to do the one thing we came to do, we took the El from O’Hare and made our way downtown. It was a strange day. Our first priority was getting coffee, so we stopped at the Blue Bottle in River North so we could plan the rest of our bonus afternoon. Within minutes, it began pouring rain and didn’t stop for a couple of hours. We didn’t mind. It gave us a chance to go through travel photos and catch up on work emails so we wouldn’t feel so inundated on Monday morning. When the rain finally died down, we had just enough time to swing by Boystown and catch a brief glimpse of Market Days before heading to Fulton Market for our bottle pickup.
In the end, we couldn’t pick up our bottle at The Aviary as it is closed on Sundays. Instead, their amazing staff passed it off to the team at Next, who greeted us excitedly with our very own bottle of Rhine Hall Strawberry Brandy. After seven years of searching and false starts, we finally had this incredible, elusive bottle.
Happy Gotcha Day to this bottle: August 9, 2026.
Aside from the spirits used in the Dusty Bottle series—a selection of six cocktails in The Aviary Cocktail Book made from vintage liquor dating as far back as 1900—this bottle of brandy wins the award for being the most difficult to acquire of any of the roughly 300 different bottles called for throughout The Aviary Cocktail Book. The only bottle to rival this is Old New Orleans Cajun Spice Rum, a daunting find in its own right for various reasons, including the fact that their distillery burned down and permanently closed in 2021.
I’m not a superstitious person, but I have come to view synchronicities in my life as signs that I am on the right track. Whenever I take some big step or achieve a breakthrough in my creative projects, I tend to notice long-lost puzzle pieces finally falling into place. Randomly discovering the brandy on The Aviary’s menu and later acquiring it as the result of an unplanned stopover in Chicago have given me a huge boost in motivation towards taking on some of the most challenging cocktails in the book. But as luck would have it, this wasn’t my only major score of the summer. My trip to Atlanta in July was not only to reconnect with one of my best friends, but to pick up the three bottles of Old New Orleans Cajun Spice Rum she helped me snag just outside the city—likely some of the last remaining bottles in existence. Both the rum and the brandy (along with a whopping nine other bottles) are used in a cocktail called Cawberry Strobbler—a recipe that until recently seemed plagued by the number of substitutions I’d have to make. I was excited to see the stars align once again and eager to try this epic cocktail I’ve been dreaming about for years.
Thanks for reading.
Whether you're a fellow home bartender, photographer, writer, collector, or simply enjoyed the story, I'd love to hear from you at hello@gayviary.com.